US News Bulletin report

His Daughters Cried While He Spoke


Jose Del Real stood on a stage in a park and looked out at hundreds of neighbors holding angry signs. Immigration agents had come to their town and begun rounding up friends and family. His daughters sat in the front row, crying.

That image stays with me. Not because it is dramatic, but because it is ordinary in the worst way: a father speaking in public while his children are frightened beside him.

The scene was in Dodge City, Kansas. The Associated Press reported that the crowd had gathered after immigration enforcement operations in late September. Residents said masked officers knocked on doors before dawn, stopped cars at intersections, and left families afraid to leave home. Businesses closed. Some children stopped going to school.

The federal agency said it detained 104 people from southwest Kansas. That number is precise. What it cannot explain is why so many people in one town felt the government had arrived without warning, without clear answers, and without enough regard for the people left behind.

What people saw

Del Real is an Army veteran who served two tours in Iraq. He had not voted in a decade. He told the crowd, “None of this matters if you do not vote. Let’s go vote.”

His message was not complicated. It was a plea from someone who had come to believe that silence had a cost.

The neighbors around him were “voicing their anger at immigration agents.” That is the documented description of the gathering: hundreds of people, furious signs, a park, a stage, and a speaker whose own daughters were crying.

I understand why people might read that scene and reach for a political conclusion. The election that followed became part of the story. Dodge City and two neighboring counties, long Republican strongholds, swung sharply to the left. That shift helped elect a Democratic U.S. senator from Kansas for the first time in nearly a century.

But the vote is not the whole story. The vote came after people had already lived through the raids.

The part that should worry us

A government can say it is enforcing immigration law. It can say it is pursuing people who have violated that law. Those are serious responsibilities, and the country needs a workable immigration system.

The question is what happens when enforcement reaches into a community so broadly that neighbors cannot tell who is being pursued, why, or when it will end.

Dodge City Commissioner Rick Sowers said local officials learned about the operation the same way residents did: through social media or unmarked trucks appearing on neighbors’ lawns. He said the city sought answers about who agents were looking for, who was in charge, and how long they would stay. He said those answers never came.

That is a problem even for people who support firm border enforcement. If local leaders cannot get basic information during an operation in their own city, residents are left to piece together the truth from rumors, videos, and fear.

The Trump administration issued statements naming five “heinous criminals” it said had been arrested. The Wichita Eagle examined that claim and found that none of the five had been apprehended during the surge. Four had been deported months earlier, and the fifth was already in prison.

The agency’s stated detention total was 104 people. The public record still does not explain, in a way residents could see and trust, how the operation matched the government’s stated purpose.

A town built on work

Dodge City sits in a region known as the Golden Triangle of Meatpacking, along with Garden City and Liberal. The area is responsible for about a quarter of the U.S. beef supply. Immigrants have settled there over decades to work at feedlots and slaughterhouses.

That matters because immigration is not an abstraction in places like this. It is a shift schedule, a family grocery store, a neighbor’s child, a coworker, a church pew, a rented house, a paycheck.

Oscar Soto works at a family-owned grocery. During the raids, he delivered food to people afraid to leave their homes. His mother came from Mexico and is in the country legally, yet he said she was terrified.

That detail deserves attention. Fear does not check documents before it enters a home. When enforcement feels unpredictable, it can reach people who are not its intended target at all.

Soto registered to vote for the first time at age 39. He said he was struck by how many young Latino voters stood in line with him.

Amy Soberanes, a local organizer, said people had asked her for years to become politically engaged. After the raids, her phone rang with registration questions.

That does not prove every person who voted did so for one reason. Elections have many causes. But it does show what can happen when a national policy becomes personal enough that people feel they must respond.

What remains unclear

It remains disputed whether the agents’ actions were necessary enforcement or excessive targeting of the community. The documented facts support the residents’ account of disruption and fear. They do not, by themselves, settle every question about individual arrests, legal authority, or the government’s larger strategy.

That distinction matters. A fair account should not pretend the fears were imagined. It also should not pretend that every detail of the operation has been publicly explained.

What is clear is that residents asked for information and did not receive enough of it. Local officials said they did not receive a list of those detained. A Republican county chairman, Scott Fischer, who supports strong borders, said the operation had “a little showmanship” and said he did not know why it was conducted that way.

When even a supporter of strict enforcement is unsettled by the manner of an operation, that is worth taking seriously.

What I keep thinking

I do not think the right response is to decide, from a distance, that everyone in Dodge City now shares one political view. The county still voted narrowly for the Republican gubernatorial candidate, according to the AP report. Some Republicans stayed with their party. Others did not.

But I do think the crying children in the front row should make us pause before we treat immigration enforcement as a policy debate conducted safely from afar.

A community was frightened. Parents were afraid to leave their homes. Children stopped going to school. People delivered groceries to neighbors who would not open their doors. Those are not talking points. They are the conditions under which people live when they no longer trust that the government will explain itself.

Del Real’s daughters were crying while he spoke. Hundreds of neighbors stood with signs. Later, many of them voted.

The vote tells us something about political consequence. The crying tells us something more basic: when public power enters a town without clarity, people remember who was left to explain it to their children.

Explore: Politics