Congress Could Turn Off the Supreme Court’s Lights
A Supreme Court justice has said Congress could “turn off the lights” at the Court. Justice Samuel Alito made the remark while warning that federal lawmakers could use their control over spending to disrupt the Court’s work.
“Congress can turn off the lights at the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening if they want to defund their activities,” Alito said at the Federalist Society’s annual Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner, according to reporting by The Hill.
The statement is blunt. It is also not a claim that Congress has already done it. It is a warning about what Congress could try to do.
What Alito said
Alito spoke about the independence of the judiciary. He said Congress has many ways it could pressure or limit the Court, or at least attempt to do so.
He also said that preserving judicial independence matters because, if it were eliminated, “the Constitution as adopted in 1789 will no longer be the same.”
That is a serious constitutional claim. But it is worth separating the warning from the legal reality.
Congress does control federal spending. The judiciary’s annual appropriations are generally included in the Financial Services and General Government appropriations bill.
That means Congress can decide how much money the Supreme Court receives for staff, security, facilities, and other operating needs. It does not automatically mean Congress can erase the Court’s constitutional authority.
The line Congress cannot easily cross
The Constitution protects the compensation of federal judges while they remain in office. Article III says judges’ pay “shall not be diminished during their Continuance in Office.”
So Congress cannot simply cut a sitting Supreme Court justice’s salary and call it a budget cut.
But the Court needs more than salaries. It needs clerks, security, building maintenance, technology, travel, and the ordinary machinery that lets nine justices hear cases and issue decisions. Those needs depend on appropriations.
A Congress that wanted to squeeze the Court could reduce or delay that money. The legal and practical result would depend on what it did, how it did it, and how courts reviewed the action.
That is the part that deserves caution. The power of the purse is real. Its limits are real too. Alito’s warning does not settle either question.
Why the warning lands now
The remarks came shortly after Democrats won control of both the House and Senate. Some Democrats and outside groups have previously discussed using a congressional vote to pressure the Court over its operations.
Alito did not directly mention the midterm results in the reported remarks. Still, the timing is hard to ignore.
When one party controls Congress and another controls the presidency, budget fights become political weapons. That is normal in Washington. What is unusual is hearing a sitting justice describe the Court as vulnerable enough that Congress could, in his words, stop everything from happening.
My first reaction was that the phrase sounded alarmist. Then I thought about what “turn off the lights” would mean in practice. It would not mean the justices disappear. It would mean the institution around them becomes harder to run.
A court without staff, secure facilities, and basic support cannot function as a modern institution. The justices may still hold their offices and salaries. The work of deciding cases could become slower, thinner, and more difficult.
That is not the same as abolishing the Supreme Court. But it could weaken it in ways ordinary people would feel.
What it means for the public
Most people do not follow appropriations bills. They notice when a case takes longer, when access to justice becomes harder, or when public confidence in the courts falls.
The Supreme Court decides issues that reach into daily life: voting, health care, immigration, free speech, criminal procedure, and the limits of federal power. Its decisions can change the rules people live under.
If Congress and the Court enter a sustained funding conflict, the public should ask a simple question: is this a legitimate check on spending, or an effort to make the Court unable to do its job?
There is a difference between oversight and sabotage. Congress has a duty to oversee public money. It also has a duty to preserve the separation of powers.
Those duties can collide. When they do, the answer should not depend on which party holds power.
What remains unknown
No law defunding the Supreme Court has been identified in the reporting around Alito’s remarks.
It is also unclear what specific funding action, if any, Congress might pursue. A broad cutoff, a narrow restriction, or a delay in appropriations could raise very different legal questions.
The Court has not announced that its operations are at risk. Alito’s comments were a warning, not an announcement of a shutdown.
That distinction matters. It is easy to turn a warning into a headline about a crisis that has not happened. It is harder, and more useful, to ask whether the warning describes a real vulnerability.
It does.
Congress holds the money. The Constitution protects judges’ pay. Between those two facts sits a wide and unsettled space. Alito has named it. The rest of the country should pay attention before the lights actually go out.
Browse: Politics