US News Bulletin report

Christian Nationalists See Republican Losses as a Chance to Replace MAGA


The losses stung. For many Christian nationalists, President Donald Trump’s return to the White House had felt like proof that their movement belonged at the center of Republican power. Now, after the party’s recent midterm defeats, some of them are treating the setback differently: not as an ending, but as an opening.

That is the striking shift. Christian nationalist groups once celebrated Trump’s return as a victory for their cause. They now see the Republican Party’s election losses as a chance to supplant his “Make America Great Again” movement with their own vision for American society.

What changed

The change is not simply disappointment. It is a claim about power.

Pastor Joel Webbon organized a three-day conference in Irving, Texas, called “Christ is King: America After Trump.” It drew more than 1,000 people. The gathering brought together Christian nationalist organizers, far-right media figures, and political activists to discuss what should come after Trump and how a more explicitly Christian political movement might take shape.

Webbon’s movement seeks a theocratic government and a patriarchal society. He argues that the midterms shattered Trump’s coalition and gave his own movement room to gain influence.

His stated plan has three parts. The first, in his view, was achieved by the Republican midterm wipeout. The second is building political machinery: door knockers, campaign donors, and phone banks. The third is winning elected office, ideally the presidency, though he also said the movement needs at least a couple of governors or Senate victories.

I read that plan with caution. It is easy to dismiss a small faction as noise. It is harder to dismiss a faction that sees a party’s loss as a recruiting opportunity.

A coalition under strain

The broader religious right did not respond to the midterms with one voice. The results exposed disagreements that had been building for some time.

White evangelical voters remained strongly Republican. Religion News Service reported that 82% supported Republicans in the 2026 midterms, although fewer turned out to vote. But Catholic support wavered, as did support among young voters and Latino voters.

That matters because Trump’s coalition was never only religious conservatives. It included Christians, young men, and Latino voters who wanted a better economy. The coalition proved fragile when economic pressures, an unpopular conflict, and disagreements over leadership piled up.

Some religious conservatives blamed voters who stayed home. Others blamed Trump’s leadership, the economy, or rival influencers. The disagreement is important. It shows that “the religious right” is not one organized bloc with one leader and one agenda.

Anthony Bradley, a research fellow at the Acton Institute, told Religion News Service that there is no single religious right comparable to the Moral Majority of the 1980s. Instead, he described competing factions arguing over what it means to be religiously conservative.

Why the opening matters

The Christian nationalist effort is not necessarily the same thing as the wider religious right. Many religious conservatives want influence within the Republican Party. Some Christian nationalists want something more fundamental: a political order shaped around their religious and social beliefs.

The distinction matters for ordinary voters. A party can absorb religious conservatives without adopting a theocratic program. But if a faction organizes donors, canvassers, phone banks, and candidates around a more extreme agenda, it can change what the party debates, nominates, and defends.

The conference’s guest list made that possibility harder to treat as fringe chatter. Nick Fuentes, an avowed white nationalist, appeared as a surprise special guest. He described the midterms as having effectively dethroned Trump as the party’s leader.

Fuentes’s presence does not prove that every attendee shares his views. It does show the company and ideas circulating around this effort. That is worth noticing without pretending it settles every question about the movement’s reach.

What remains unknown

The most important question is whether this faction can turn a conference into durable political power.

Webbon himself does not expect his goal to arrive soon. He and his allies hope the election losses will let them “pick up the pieces” and begin building toward it.

That is a long project. It requires money, candidates, volunteers, media attention, and voters willing to support a program that many Republicans would reject. The reported attendance at the Texas conference is a measure of interest, not a measure of electoral strength.

There is also disagreement over language. The Associated Press and other outlets describe the Christian nationalist vision as extremist. Supporters would dispute that label or define their goals differently. Readers should separate the documented facts from the characterization: the movement’s stated goals include a theocratic government and patriarchal society; whether those goals should be called extremist is a judgment that remains contested among observers.

The quiet risk

My first reaction was alarm. My second was to slow down.

Election losses often produce factional fights. Parties argue about who failed, who belongs, and what message should come next. That is normal political weather.

But this fight has a particular edge. Trump’s MAGA movement built a broad coalition around economic grievance, immigration, cultural conflict, and personal loyalty to Trump. Christian nationalists are now proposing to replace that coalition’s center of gravity with a more explicit religious and hierarchical program.

The danger is not that one conference will remake the Republican Party overnight. It probably will not. The danger is quieter: a party under pressure may become more open to factions that offer certainty, discipline, and a ready-made explanation for defeat.

For voters who care about religious liberty, pluralism, and the basic rules of democratic competition, that is not a reason for panic. It is a reason to pay attention.

Explore: Politics