US News Bulletin report

California Can Still Require Doctors to Learn About Implicit Bias


California doctors must keep learning about implicit bias. The Supreme Court declined on Monday to hear a challenge to that rule, leaving a lower-court decision in place and raising a question Justice Clarence Thomas says reaches beyond medicine: when can a state require a private person to speak?

The case began with Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, a California ophthalmologist who teaches continuing medical education. She and Do No Harm argued that California cannot require private instructors to include implicit-bias material in courses doctors need for license renewal. They said the requirement forces them to convey a viewpoint they oppose.

The Supreme Court did not decide that California’s rule is constitutional. It denied review, which means the Ninth Circuit’s ruling remains in effect. Three justices, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and Neil Gorsuch, said they would have heard the case. Four votes were needed.

What California requires

California’s 2019 law requires qualifying continuing medical education courses to include instruction on implicit bias. The state began enforcing the requirement in 2022. The courses are privately run and privately accredited, but doctors must complete them to renew their licenses.

The material is not a demand that a doctor agree with a political party or endorse a particular law. It asks instructors to address how unconscious attitudes can affect medical care and health outcomes. The state’s position is that this is professional education, connected to patient care.

That distinction matters. A license is a privilege tied to public duties, and states have long set requirements for people who practice regulated professions. But a licensing rule can still raise a First Amendment problem if it makes a private speaker repeat the government’s message.

The court’s silence

The lower courts treated the required courses as government speech. In that view, California is not forcing private people to express the state’s views; it is deciding what content must be part of a state-approved educational requirement.

Thomas disagreed. In a dissent joined by Alito, he wrote that the requirement is not speech by a government actor. It is a requirement that private speakers communicate particular messages. He argued that heavy state regulation does not turn private expression into government speech.

His concern is easy to understand, even for someone who does not share his conclusion. If the government can call a private course “government speech” because it regulates it closely, the label could become a way to avoid the usual constitutional scrutiny. A state could require a person to say something, then call the statement its own.

That possibility is what gives me pause. It is not because implicit-bias education is inherently suspect. It is because the legal reasoning could matter in settings far removed from a medical classroom.

Why it reaches further

Thomas warned that the ruling could allow states to compel private citizens to provide testimony or speech for use in legal proceedings. The documented record does not show that California has done that in this case. It shows that Thomas believes the Ninth Circuit’s reasoning could support such a result.

That is an important difference. A warning about where a rule may lead is not proof that the rule has already been used that way. The Supreme Court’s denial also does not establish a national rule that states may compel private speech. It simply leaves the California decision standing and leaves the constitutional question unresolved.

The dispute is therefore narrower than some headlines suggest. California requires certain continuing education for physicians. The challengers say that requirement crosses into compelled speech. The lower courts accepted California’s characterization of the courses as government speech. The Supreme Court chose not to resolve that disagreement.

What ordinary people should watch

For most people, this case will not change what they say at dinner or post online tomorrow. It concerns a specific professional licensing requirement in California. But it concerns something familiar: the line between a government setting standards and a government telling people what to say.

Doctors are not ordinary speakers in every respect. They hold a state license, serve patients, and agree to professional rules as a condition of practice. That gives California a stronger reason to require training connected to medical care. It does not answer every question about how far a state may go.

The Court’s refusal to hear the case is not a victory for either side in the usual sense. It is a decision to wait. California’s rule remains in force. The challengers’ First Amendment argument remains unanswered by the nation’s highest court.

Thomas wanted the Court to clarify when state regulation turns private speech into government speech. Alito joined him. Gorsuch said he would have granted review. The other justices did not explain why they declined.

That silence is the part worth sitting with. The Court did not say California’s approach is sound. It did not say the challengers are wrong. It left a real constitutional question open, while a state requirement continues to shape what private instructors must teach.

The issue will not disappear. States regulate professions, schools, workplaces, and public services. Each time they do, they must decide whether they are setting standards or recruiting private people to carry a state message. This case did not settle that line. It showed how unsettled it remains.

More on: Law